Business growth exposed weak economics.
A price list can look reasonable while the economics beneath it go unexamined.
As the salon grew, the question changed. It was no longer how much prices should rise, but what each service needed to contribute and what the business kept after labor and discounts. Answering it took several connected efforts, not one price change.
Price-first approach
- Previous price
- Competitor price
- Percentage increase
Decision-model approach
- Staff estimates of service time
- Local market reference
- Cost structure and product cost
- Customer transition risk
- Modeled economics
Competitor pricing was context, not the sole basis for what to charge.
What the pricing had to support
Where does every $100 go?
Before changing prices, I traced where each dollar of revenue went.
I built a simplified diagnostic: for every $100 of revenue, how much went to employee labor, to discounts, and to other operating costs. My first estimate put employee labor at $58.99.
Then I found a limit in GroomMore's historical reporting. Historical commission reports could reflect current commission rates rather than the rates in effect at the time. So I rebuilt the labor measure from actual payroll information in Square: $47.25 in employee compensation plus $5.55 in employer payroll taxes, or $52.80 per $100.
Where does every $100 go?
Per $100 of revenue
First estimateFrom GroomMore commission reports
Employee labor: $58.99 of every $100
CorrectedRebuilt from actual Square payroll
Employee labor: $52.80 of every $100$47.25 employee compensation + $5.55 employer payroll taxes
Employee labor Everything else in each $100
What is left after employee labor alone
- Revenue$100.00
- Employee labor (corrected)− $52.80
- DiscountsAnalyzed separately in the discount sections. Not netted here.
- Other operating costsNot fully reconciled in this diagnostic.
Left after employee labor alone
$47.20
Before discounts and other operating costs.
Not profitThere was no fully reconciled profit-and-loss statement, and many operating costs sit outside this simplified view, so this remainder is not profit.
Sanitized diagnostic drawn for this page from the analysis. It shows per-$100 aggregates only: no raw statements or payroll records, and no owner, contractor, or individual compensation.
A measurement correction, not an operational improvement
Moving from $58.99 to $52.80 changed how labor was measured, not how the business operated. The first estimate relied on a report that could not show historical rates. Better data changed the model.
PrincipleThe analysis improved as the evidence improved.
Redesigning labor economics without cutting projected employee earnings.
Labor consumed too much of each revenue dollar. The goal was not to cut employee earnings.
Employee labor, corrected to $52.80 of every $100 of gross sales in 2026, took too large a share of revenue. The design problem was how to reduce labor as a share of revenue without reducing projected annual employee earnings.
The compensation plan combined higher service prices, adjusted commission percentages for employed groomers, and employer payroll-tax modeling. It is a projected 2027 model. It does not say employees have already experienced it, that 2026 pay was reduced, or that annual earnings are guaranteed.
A 2027 compensation model, not a result that has already happened.
Employee labor as a share of gross sales
How the share falls
- Higher service prices
- Adjusted commission percentages
- Employer payroll-tax modeling
A lower labor share of revenue, while maintaining projected annual employee earnings
- Modeled staffing
- 3 employed Groomers, all modeled at 42% commission, plus the Owner
- Employer payroll taxes
- Included, using Jo Jo's actual Square employer-tax experience
- Owner
- Outside the employee-labor measure
Projected annual improvement from the labor redesign, on the existing sales base~$25,927/year
Sanitized comparison drawn for this page. It shows aggregate shares only: no names, wages, or individual earnings.
Business sustainability and employee earnings, designed together
This was not the company against its employees. The same plan that lowers labor as a share of revenue was built to maintain projected annual employee earnings, so the two goals were balanced rather than traded off.
PrincipleThe goal was not to cut employee earnings.
The market set a reference point.
Pricing didn't come from one competitor or one spreadsheet.
Bark Avenue provided a direct local benchmark, while broader market and community signals provided context. No single competitor stood in for the whole market, and the previous Spa prices weren't uniformly far below it: some were close to the local benchmark and some were only modestly lower.
Direct local benchmark
- Bark Avenue, the strongest retained direct competitor benchmark
- Local competitor pricing research
Market and community context
- Census and local income and demographic context
- Local demand and dog-ownership context
- Competitor busyness
- Local social posts about salon perceptions and pricing
- Google reviews and reputation positioning
PrincipleThe market set a reference point. The work required to deliver the service determined when that reference point was not enough.
Service times came from the people doing the work.
Staff estimated how long each service took, start to finish.
The source is "Jo Jo's Pet Spa — Service Times via Staff Interviews," from August 19, 2026. I used it to compare how long services took with how the menu defined them.
Not stopwatch measurements, a formal time study, or durations derived from the booking system.
How to read these estimates
- Estimates from staff interviews, so directional rather than precisely measured
- Individual groomer attribution was not recorded
- Each figure is total service time from beginning to end. It does not separate active groomer labor, drying time, or kennel time
- For Shave, Deshed, Sport, and Styling, the total already includes the Spa/Bath portion
- Skin Therapy used the same total-time estimates as Deshed. It differs in product and cost, not in time
Used to find where the menu needed a closer look, not as a precise cost model.
Where the menu hid different amounts of work.
Setting the staff estimates beside the service definitions showed three different situations.
The count didn't grow for complexity's sake. Deshed and Skin Therapy were split because materially different amounts of work had been grouped under one definition.
Confirmed
Bath & Spa
Already used size and coat categories that generally lined up with the staff-estimated duration structure.
Reframed
Shave, Sport, and Styling
Understood as total appointment commitments, with the Spa/Bath base included in the time.
Restructured
Deshed and Skin Therapy
Previously size-only. Coat length wasn't represented, even though staff estimates showed materially different total service time.
From 8 size-only categories to 16 size-and-coat variants
816service variants across Deshed and Skin Therapy
Before (size only): 8 categories
Deshed
- Small
- Medium
- Large
- Giant
Skin Therapy
- Small
- Medium
- Large
- Giant
After (size + coat): 16 variants
Deshed
- SmallShort coatLong coat
- MediumShort coatLong coat
- LargeShort coatLong coat
- GiantShort coatLong coat
Skin Therapy
- SmallShort coatLong coat
- MediumShort coatLong coat
- LargeShort coatLong coat
- GiantShort coatLong coat
Illustrative: the service structure before and after, drawn for this page. Not a copy of the price book.
Why the split mattered.
Some apparent price increases were corrections to the service definition itself.
Under the old structure, a Large Deshed was a single category. Staff estimates put a short-coat Large at about 75 minutes of total service time and a long-coat Large at about 150, roughly twice as long, for work one category had covered. The goal was to align revenue more closely with the work required, which started with defining the work correctly.
Staff-estimated total service time
Total service time, beginning to end, as estimated by staff
Large Deshed
BeforeOne size-only “Large Deshed” category
Large, short coat~75 min
Large, long coat~150 min
About twice the estimated total service time, previously covered by a single category.
Giant Skin Therapy
BeforeOne size-only “Giant Skin Therapy” category
Giant, short coat~110 min
Giant, long coat~180 min
Another size where one category covered materially different amounts of work.
Selected examples from the August 19, 2026 staff estimates, drawn for this page. Not stopwatch measurements, and not the full matrix.
Market price was one input, not the answer.
Several kinds of evidence fed each pricing decision.
Business economics, the market reference, service-time evidence, dog and service characteristics, product cost where relevant, and customer transition risk all fed the pricing decisions. The market gave a reference point. The work behind a service decided when that wasn't enough.
How a price was decided
Evidence
- Business economics, including labor share and employee earnings
- Market reference
- Service-time and workload evidence
- Dog and service characteristics
- Product cost, where relevant
- Customer transition risk
No single input decided the price.
Pricing decision
- Some prices increased
- Some prices decreased, where supported
- Target pricing and transition pricing set separately
- A phased plan for introducing the changes
Kept qualitative here; the price book is not shown.
Modeled economics
- The proposed menu evaluated on the same set of appointments
- Service volume and mix held constant
- A service-level contribution comparison
Estimated impact before the complete plan was implemented. Service-time research informed the decisions; this comparison applied the model's contribution assumptions to the proposed menu.
Illustrative. Synthesized from the engagement's pricing research and model logic; not an original project artifact.
Service-level contribution
Service-level contribution estimated how much service revenue remained after the variable costs represented in the pricing model, using a fixed set of appointments and holding service volume and mix constant. It was decision-support economics, not salon-wide operating profit or net profit.
PrincipleMarket price was one input, not the sole answer.
Target price and transition price were two decisions.
Where prices should end up and how customers get there were designed separately.
Phase 3 is the intended target pricing architecture. Phase 1 was the first customer transition. Appointments already booked before Phase 1 began kept their previous prices, which reduced disruption while the move toward the intended model began.
Transition pricing and target pricing
Phase 1
Transition price
ImplementedFrom September 1, 2026
- The first customer transition
- Appointments already booked kept their previous prices (grandfathered)
- Some prices reached their target right away; others moved part of the way
Phase 2
Intermediate stage
Considered — dropped
- It would have existed only briefly
- It added operational complexity
- The benefit didn't justify that complexity
Phase 3
Target price
Planned — not yet in effectEffective January 1, 2027
- The intended target pricing architecture
- Not implemented
Summary of the phased plan, drawn for this page.
PrincipleThe target price and the transition price were two different design decisions.
How representative prices moved.
A few examples, not the full menu.
Each example shows the previous price, the Phase 1 transition price, and the Phase 3 target. Some services reached their target in Phase 1. Larger corrections were staged over time.
Representative price progression
Dog Bath / Spa, Small, short coat
- Before
- $39.33
- Phase 1
- $45
- Phase 3 target
- $45
Reached its intended target in Phase 1.
Dog Bath / Spa, Giant, short coat
- Before
- $77.03
- Phase 1
- $81
- Phase 3 target
- $90
A phased transition toward the target.
Sport, Large
- Before
- $41.08
- Phase 1
- $44
- Phase 3 target
- $75
A larger correction, staged over time.
Styling, Large
- Before
- $61.62
- Phase 1
- $65
- Phase 3 target
- $90
A larger correction, staged over time.
Deshed, Large, long coat
Service definition changed
- Before
- $30.81
- Legacy size-only Large Deshed
- Phase 1
- $40
- Phase 3 target
- $60
It reflects both a price change and a change in how the service is defined, so it isn't a like-for-like comparison.
Skin Therapy, Large, long coat
Service definition changed
- Before
- $30.81
- Legacy size-only Large Skin Therapy
- Phase 1
- $145
- Phase 3 target
- $145
The legacy definition didn't separate coat length, even though staff estimated roughly 150 minutes of total service time for Large Long Skin Therapy and Deshed. This is a structural correction, not a like-for-like increase.
Selected examples from the previous, Phase 1, and Phase 3 menus. Not the full price book.
Phase 3 targets are planned for January 1, 2027 and are not yet in effect.
Phase 1 in practice.
September showed a partial rollout. Just over half of appointments included a new-price service.
Phase 1 pricing began September 1, 2026, and appointments already booked kept their previous prices. A September audit confirmed Phase 1 pricing was appearing in live appointments. That verifies implementation and, on its own, says nothing about financial performance.
September 2026 appointments and the prices actually applied.
Phase 1 pricing, from September 1, 2026, with grandfathering.
September 2026 appointments by price menu
183September 2026 appointments
- 79 priced entirely on the previous menu (grandfathered) (43.2%)
- 95 priced entirely on the new menu (51.9%)
- 9 with a mix of previous and new prices (4.9%)
104 / 183appointments included at least one new-price service, 56.8%
Counts from September 2026 appointment data, drawn for this page. No customer or transaction detail is shown.
What Phase 1 did to September's prices.
An early implementation check. Repricing the same observed transactions shows the estimated pricing effect.
Phase 1 produced an estimated 2.3% pricing lift in September. It is a modeled figure. The appointments, services, prices, and transaction mix were observed, and the model asks what those exact transactions would have produced under the previous menu.
Comparing the same observed transactions at September's actual prices with what they would have produced under the previous menu gives an estimated $366 in incremental revenue.
The effect wasn't a uniform increase. By category, the reconstruction shows increases for dog bath, haircut add-ons, and Deshed, and decreases for cats and a secondary category. It is a reconstruction of the same transactions and carries no causal claim beyond that.
+$366
estimated September incremental revenue from Phase 1 pricing
~2.3%
estimated September pricing lift
A modeled pricing effect on the same observed transactions. It is not growth in total sales, and it is not profit.
How this was estimated
- Observed: September appointments, services, actual prices, transaction mix, and rollout exposure
- Modeled: what those same transactions would have produced under the previous menu
- The difference, about $366, is roughly 2.3% of what the same transactions would have produced at previous-menu prices
- Built from September transactions, a different analysis from the future combined-plan model later on this page
A modeled pricing effect on the same transaction mix, not a measure of total sales growth or of profit.
- Dog bath
+$228.84
- Haircut add-ons
+$123.77
- Deshed
+$66.41
- Cats
−$35.96
- Secondary
−$17.40
- Total
+$365.65 (about $366)
Auditing the old discount process.
Discounts set how much of a service's value the business gave back, so I audited how they were recorded.
I reviewed January through June 2026 sales. About 9% of discounted transactions were either confirmed problematic or could not be cleanly validated. That is not a 9% error rate: only one transaction was a confirmed error, and most of the exception group simply couldn't be verified from the available records.
January–June 2026 sales transactions.
Discount audit, January–June 2026
January–June 2026
1,135 sales transactions
307 had a discount (27.0%)
- 277 could be explained and classified (90.2%)
- 26 unresolved or unverifiable
- 1 confirmed error
27 / 307of discounted transactions were confirmed problematic or could not be cleanly validated, or about 8.8%
Counts from the January–June 2026 audit, drawn for this page. No transaction, customer, or staff detail is shown.
What the audit does and doesn't say
The old process didn't capture enough structured information to make every historical discount auditable. It does not show that staff applied discounts incorrectly.
Making discounts easier to see.
The response was structure, with named discounts that carry their own context.
Errors could still happen, but they became easier to see and investigate. There isn't yet a comparable six-month period after the change, so no post-implementation error rate is claimed.
Discount tracking began July 29, 2026.
Gap in the old process
Discount type and rate weren't always recoverable
Redesigned control
Named discount codes record the type and rate
Gap in the old process
The reason for a discount wasn't always clear
Redesigned control
Each code carries its reason
Gap in the old process
Transaction context was hard to reconstruct
Redesigned control
Context and application details are captured where available
Redesigning the loyalty reward.
A reward that cost a different amount every time became a fixed credit.
The old reward, a free bath after 10 visits, varied widely in value because bath prices varied by dog and service. The new reward is a fixed $30 Loyalty Credit after 10 qualifying visits of at least $30.
The revised loyalty credit was in use by September 18, 2026.
Before: free bath
- 10 visits
- A free bath
- Reward value varied with the dog and service
After: fixed credit
- 10 qualifying visits, each at least $30
- A fixed $30 Loyalty Credit
- Reward cost is predictable
Transition protections. Existing points were preserved, and customers already at 10 visits could still receive the old free-bath reward.
- Observed, January–June 2026
55 loyalty redemptions had a historical reward value of $3,222.26, an average of $58.59 each, or $2.83 per $100 of gross sales.
- Modeled replay
The same 55 rewards at a fixed $30 would have cost $1,650, which is $1,572.26 less over six months, or about 48.8% lower. A modeled replay of historical redemptions, not a measured result.
- Annualized benchmark
A simple annualization of that historical difference is about $3,145 a year. It is supporting evidence only and is not added to the integrated projection later on this page, because the discount redesign already contains the Loyalty change.
The broader discount program.
Loyalty was one part of a wider redesign of customer-facing discounts.
The redesigned program is modeled against historical sales volume. It has not been measured after the change.
On the existing 2026-equivalent sales base, the redesign contributes about $4,300 a year (projected) to the integrated figure later on this page. That amount already includes the Loyalty redesign, so Loyalty savings are not added to it again.
Before
- Loyalty: free bath after 10 visits
- Friends & Family: 25%
- New Client: 15%
- Review: 10%
- Boarding discount: offered
Redesigned program
- Loyalty: fixed $30 credit after 10 qualifying visits of at least $30
- Friends & Family: 20%
- New Client: 15% (unchanged)
- Review: 10% (unchanged)
- Boarding discount: removed
Projected, modeled comparison. Not a measured post-change rate.
31.6%
Projected reduction in customer-facing discount cost
PROJECTED
Modeled customer-facing discount cost, from $5.97 per $100 of gross sales to $4.08, a difference of $1.89 retained per $100.
A modeled, like-for-like comparison of customer-facing discounts only. It does not cover all discounts or marketing cost, and it is not a measured result.
What Phase 3 prices would do to the same workload.
Repricing the same historical appointments with the planned 2027 price book.
I replayed 596 fully paid appointments from June through August, the same underlying workload, using the planned Phase 3 price book. The same work would generate about 12.64% more service revenue, a projected pricing effect on the same workload. It is not demand growth, appointment growth, or realized sales growth.
Applied to the current annualized workload, that is roughly $28,588 of projected additional gross service revenue. The business doesn't keep all of it. Under the 2027 structure, 41.34% goes to employee labor (projected) and 4.08% to customer-facing discounts and Loyalty, which leaves 54.58%, or about $15,603 a year.
Phase 3 is planned for January 1, 2027 and is not yet in effect.
+12.64%
projected service revenue from the same workload
The same work, repriced. Not demand growth, appointment growth, or realized sales growth.
Where a projected price effect goes
Employee labor
Projected share of the increase that goes to employee labor
41.34%
Customer-facing discounts and Loyalty
Projected share given back in discounts
4.08%
Remains before other expenses
Projected, about $15,603 a year
54.58%
Projected additional gross service revenue
Not money kept. Only the remaining share counts toward the integrated figure below.
~$28,588/year
Drawn for this page from the 2027 model. Shares of the projected additional gross service revenue; bar lengths are the true shares.
Putting the changes together.
Three parts of the program add up to one projected figure.
The integrated projected figure is about $45,800 a year, roughly $3,800 a month, retained after employee labor and customer-facing discounts and before owner compensation and other operating expenses. It assumes about the same amount of customer work as 2026: no extra appointments from a third employed Groomer, no demand growth, and no added utilization. Any upside from added capacity is outside this forecast.
It is not net profit, operating profit, EBITDA, cash flow, owner income, or guaranteed revenue. Owner compensation, rent, card processing, supplies, utilities, software, insurance, equipment, marketing, accounting, and other taxes all still come out of what remains.
A 2027 model on the same workload, not a measured result.
~$45,800/year
projected additional amount retained after employee labor + customer-facing discounts
~$3,800/month
projected, the same amount per month
Remaining after employee labor and customer-facing discounts, before owner compensation and other operating expenses. Not profit.
How the projected amount reconciles
Lower employee-labor burden
Projected: 52.80% → 41.34% of gross sales, on the existing sales base
+$25,927
Discount + Loyalty redesign
Projected: $5.97 → $4.08 per $100. It already contains the Loyalty redesign, so Loyalty savings are not added again.
+$4,275
Contribution from higher service prices
Projected: 12.64% more service revenue, after employee labor and discounts
+$15,603
Total projected additional retained
About $45,800 a year, or $3,817 a month
+$45,805
Drawn for this page from the 2027 model. Bar lengths are each part's true share of the total.
What is and isn't in the number
It counts employee labor (with employer payroll taxes) and customer-facing discounts, including Loyalty. It does not add the separate Loyalty replay on top, because the discount redesign already contains it. It is a projected 2027 figure, not a measured result or a guarantee.
What a sales dollar looks like.
Two different denominators, kept separate on purpose.
The first comparison is per $100 of actual gross sales in each year. The second takes the customer work that produced $100 of sales in 2026 and asks what the same work would generate, and keep, at projected 2027 prices. Both stop before owner compensation and other operating expenses, and neither is profit.
The 2027 rows are modeled on the same underlying workload.
Per-$100 economics, two denominators
Employee laborCustomer-facing discountsRemains before other expenses
Per $100 of ACTUAL gross sales
Each row is that year's own sales.
2026$100.00
- $52.80 Employee labor
- $5.97 Customer-facing discounts
- $41.23 Remains before other expenses
2027 projectedProjected$100.00
- $41.34 Employee labor
- $4.08 Customer-facing discounts
- $54.58 Remains before other expenses
13.35 percentage points more of each sales dollar remains before owner compensation and other operating expenses, projected.
Per $100 of 2026 WORK (the same workload)
The customer work that produced $100 of sales in 2026.
2026, that work produced$100.00
- $52.80 Employee labor
- $5.97 Customer-facing discounts
- $41.23 Remains before other expenses
Same work at projected 2027 pricesProjected$112.64
- $46.57 Employee labor
- $4.60 Customer-facing discounts
- $61.48 Remains before other expenses
+$20.25 more retained for every $100 of 2026-equivalent work ($41.23 → $61.48), projected.
$61.48 is 54.58% of $112.64. Amounts are rounded.
Drawn for this page from the 2027 model. Within each panel the bars share one scale.
Don't confuse $54.58 with $61.48
$54.58 is what remains from every ACTUAL $100 of projected 2027 gross sales. $61.48 is what remains from the $112.64 that the same workload would generate at projected 2027 prices, work that produced $100 in 2026. They answer different questions.
A separate, future model.
This analysis is separate from the September estimate and from the integrated projection.
The September estimate measures what Phase 1 did to actual transactions. The integrated projection above puts the labor, discount, and pricing changes on one basis. The model below is a third, separate analysis. It compares the combined pricing plan, Phase 1 and Phase 3 together, with the previous menu on 67 comparable September 2026 appointments. It is a future combined-plan model: not a September result, not the observed effect of Phase 1, not the projected $45,800 figure, not the 12.64% price replay, not growth in sales or profit, and not a guarantee of future performance.
Three menus, one comparison
Modeled comparison: combined pricing plan vs previous menu
14.9%
PROJECTED
Projected service-level contribution improvement across 67 comparable September 2026 appointments, compared with the previous menu.
- Not the September 2026 result, and not the effect of Phase 1 alone.
- A separate analysis. It is not the integrated projection, the projected 12.64% price replay, or growth in sales or profit.
- Phase 3 had not yet launched.
- Service-level contribution, not salon-wide operating profit or net profit.
- Not a measured post-launch result, and not guaranteed future performance.
Reconstructed for portfolio presentation from the documented pricing-phase comparisons and implementation records.
A reasonable price can hide unclear economics.
Improving profitability took several connected efforts: a financial diagnostic I corrected when its source proved unreliable, a labor and compensation model designed to lower labor as a share of revenue without lowering projected employee earnings, market and service-time research, a restructured service menu, phased pricing, and discount and loyalty controls that are easier to audit.
What has been observed is a partial Phase 1 rollout and an estimated September pricing lift. What is modeled or planned stays labeled that way, and its effects still need verifying after implementation.
A price is easier to defend when the work behind it is understood.